Raza Begg

Annuities explained

Four kinds of annuity, in plain English.

Annuities are contracts with insurance companies. They can grow savings, protect against some risks, or turn a lump sum into income. Each type trades off growth, safety, access and simplicity differently. Here is what each one does.

01

Fixed annuity

You deposit money and the insurer credits a fixed interest rate for a set period. The rate is declared by the insurer and may change when the period ends.

Who it suits

People who want predictable growth, no exposure to the stock market, and money they will not need for several years.

Pros

  • Predictable growth you can plan around
  • No direct market losses
  • Growth is tax-deferred until you withdraw (general rule; confirm with a tax professional)

Trade-offs

  • The rate can be reset when the initial period ends
  • Surrender charges may apply if you withdraw early
  • Growth may trail inflation or other options over time
  • Guarantees depend on the insurer's claims-paying ability

02

Fixed indexed annuity

Interest is linked to part of a market index, such as a broad stock index. A cap, participation rate or spread limits how much of the index gain you receive. Many contracts set a floor, often 0%.

Who it suits

People who want some market-linked growth but cannot accept direct market losses, and who understand that gains are limited.

Pros

  • Can credit more than a fixed rate in strong market years
  • Typically no direct market losses, subject to the contract's floor
  • Tax-deferred growth (general rule)

Trade-offs

  • Caps and participation rates limit your upside
  • Many contracts credit price return and leave out dividends
  • Some years may credit 0% interest
  • Contracts are complex, and fees or riders can reduce results
  • Surrender charges can last for years

03

Immediate annuity (SPIA)

You exchange a lump sum for a stream of income that starts within about a year. The income can last for life or for a set number of years, depending on the option you choose.

Who it suits

People who want a paycheck-style income in retirement and worry about outliving their savings. Usually suitable only for money you can commit for good.

Pros

  • Predictable income, which can cover essential bills
  • Lifetime income options are available
  • Simple to understand once the option is chosen

Trade-offs

  • Generally irreversible: the lump sum is not returned on request
  • Limited access to the money once it is annuitized
  • Income is usually not inflation-adjusted unless you buy an option for that
  • Some options stop payments at death, unless a refund or period-certain option is chosen
  • Payments depend on your age, the option and prevailing rates at purchase

04

Multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA)

A fixed rate guaranteed for a set term, typically several years. It works like a bank certificate of deposit, but it is an insurance contract, so it is not FDIC insured.

Who it suits

People who want a known rate and a known end date for money they can set aside, and who want to avoid market risk for that period.

Pros

  • Rate is guaranteed for the full term, subject to the insurer's claims-paying ability
  • Simple to compare, with a clear end date
  • Tax-deferred growth (general rule)

Trade-offs

  • Surrender charges often run for the full term
  • The renewal rate may be lower than the original rate
  • Not FDIC insured, unlike a bank CD
  • Comparing to a CD needs care, including taxes, access and insurer strength

Questions to ask before you buy any annuity

Any good advisor should be able to answer these questions clearly, in writing. If they cannot, that is useful information.

Book a consultation
  1. What is the surrender schedule, and how much would I pay to leave early?
  2. What fees, riders and caps apply, and how do they change my result?
  3. What is the insurer's financial strength rating from independent agencies?
  4. How much can I withdraw each year without a surrender charge?
  5. What happens to the money if I die early, and who is the beneficiary?
  6. How does this fit with my emergency savings and other income?